2004

WR Jamaica Rector - American Football Coaches Association (AFCA) First-Team; Associated Press Little All-America First-Team All-Purpose Back; Daktronics / CoSIDA First-Team;
QB Josh Lamberson - CoSIDA Academic First-Team;
LB Troy Tysdahl - CoSIDA Academic First-Team; OL Brad Schneider - Daktronics/CoSIDA Second-Team;
DL Steve Williams - Daktronics / CoSIDA Second-Team;
LB Adam Long - Daktronics / CoSIDA Second-Team

2003

WR Jamaica Rector - American Football Coaches Association (AFCA) First-Team; Associated Press Little All-America Second-Team

2002
OL Seth Wand - Associated Press Little All-America First-Team; American Football Coaches Association (AFC) First-Team; Daktronics/ CoSIDA First-Team

2001
OL Seth Wand - AFCA First-Team

2000
WR Tony Miles - AFCA First-Team, Daktronics/CoSIDA First-Team;
OL Andy Erpelding - Daktronics/CoSIDA First-Team;
LB Brian Williams - Daktronics/CoSIDA First-Team;
TE Steve Comer - Daktronics/CoSIDA Second-Team;
DL Aaron Becker - Daktronics/CoSIDA Second-Team

1999
OL Chad Thompson - Daktronics/CoSIDA First-Team;
WR Tony Miles - AFCA First Team;
PK David Purnell - Daktronics/CoSIDA First-Team

1998
OL Steve Coppinger - Daktronics/CoSIDA First-Team;
QB Chris Greisen - Daktronics/CoSIDA First-Team, AFCA First-Team;
DB Twan Young - Daktronics/CoSIDA First-Team;
LB Aaron Crowe - Daktronics/CoSIDA First-Team;
DL Aaron Becker - Daktronics/CoSIDA Second-Team

1997
QB Chris Greisen - AFCA First-Team;
OL Adam Dorrel - Daktronics/CoSIDA Second-Team;
DB Twan Young - Daktronics/CoSIDA Second-Team;
LB Aaron Crowe - Football Gazette Second-Team

1996
DL Matt Uhde - Daktronics/CoSIDAFirst-Team, AFCA First-Team, AP Little All-America First-Team

1995
DB Ezra Whorley - Daktronics/CoSIDA Second-Team

1991
DE Erik Petersen, AP Little All-America Second-Team

1989
DB Jason Agee - AP Little All-America First-Team

1985
WR Steve Hansley - AP Little All-America First-Team

1984
WR Steve Hansley - AP Little All-America First-Team

1939
OL Marion Rogers - AP Little All-America First-Team